Best nursing homes in Shelby County, OH
There are 4 nursing homes in Shelby County, Ohio certified by Medicare. Of the 4 with a CMS star rating, the average is 2.8 stars, compared with 3.2 statewide.
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Medicare Care Compare. We refresh our information from this source. About our data
Nursing Homes in Shelby County, OH, ranked
Sorted by CMS star rating. Facilities without a rating are listed last.
1.Ohio Living Dorothy Love
3003 West Cisco Road, Sidney, OH 45365
Non-profit · 44 beds · Part of Ohio Living Communities
- CMS high performer
★★★★★5Much above average2.Shelby Skilled Nursing and Rehabilitation
705 Fulton Street, Sidney, OH 45365
For-profit · 50 beds · Part of Michael Slyk
★★★★★3Average- ★★★★★2Below average
4.Fair Haven Shelby County
2901 Fair Road, Sidney, OH 45365
Government · 90 beds
- Special Focus candidate
★★★★★1Much below average
Compare staffing and inspections
| Nursing home | Overall | Beds | Owner type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ohio Living Dorothy Love | 5 | 44 | Non-profit |
| Shelby Skilled Nursing and Rehabilitation | 3 | 50 | For-profit |
| Momentous Health at Sidney | 2 | 51 | For-profit |
| Fair Haven Shelby County | 1 | 90 | Government |
Nursing Homes in nearby cities
- Sidney, OH (4 · 0 mi)
- Piqua, OH (2 · 10.3 mi)
- Minster, OH (1 · 12.6 mi)
- Covington, OH (1 · 15.4 mi)
- Troy, OH (2 · 15.7 mi)
- Versailles, OH (1 · 17.1 mi)
- Wapakoneta, OH (1 · 20.2 mi)
- Lakeview, OH (1 · 20.3 mi)
- Saint Marys, OH (1 · 20.3 mi)
- St Marys, OH (3 · 20.8 mi)
- Tipp City, OH (1 · 21.6 mi)
- Bellefontaine, OH (2 · 22.1 mi)
Frequently asked questions
How many nursing homes are in Shelby County, OH?
4 Medicare-certified nursing homes are listed in Shelby County, Ohio.
What is the best-rated nursing home in Shelby County, OH?
Ohio Living Dorothy Love has the highest CMS rating here (5 stars). Ratings are a good place to start, but visit and ask questions before you decide.
Do any nursing homes in Shelby County, OH have CMS warnings?
None of the nursing homes in Shelby County, OH currently carry a CMS abuse icon or Special Focus Facility status.
Helpful resources
- How to choose a nursing home: a practical checklist
- Nursing home star ratings explained
- How to read nursing home inspection citations
- Does Medicare pay for a nursing home?
- Nursing homes with the most federal fines
- Best-staffed nursing homes in the U.S.
- Nursing homes with the lowest staff turnover
- Special Focus Facility nursing homes (list)